Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

:omfg:
 
©2009 ~chrisscalf
:iconchrisscalf:

Artist's Comments

Here's a painting I've grown to hate. Why? because it was just a simple little 1 hour doodle-- not a serious effort what so ever-- and for some reason-- it has sky-rocketed to 1,128,177 views on youtube (as of this posting). But I hate it for a couple of reasons... First-- It's one of those weird tangent pieces that is supposed to depict forced perspective. Some see it, some don't.

But if you poke through the comments, every so often you get a comment about the bottom jaw being TOO BIG. And then you get others who see it as just fine, and can totally see what I saw in my head when I made it... Art is so subjective... The opinions of whether or not this is correct perspective is split right down the middle.

Anyhow... I leave it up cuz of the insane amount of hits it gets... But part of me wants to take it down since it's probably a bad representation of what I really can do.

As far as the jaw goes-- it still looks fine to me. I even did a 3D model of it, and was going to post an animated version of this painting and put it up on youtube, but never finished it. There is however, a WIP vid of it here:
[link]

Part of me does like the debating of the jaw... It truly shows how all of our perspectives in how we see things truly differs from one another. And I mean beyond art even. ;-)

Anyway... Enjoy it. Hate it. Pick it apart.. Whatever... It's fine with me. ;-)

Oh, yeah.. and the original youtube link is here:
[link]

Comments


love 1 1 joy 2 2 wow 1 1 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconalthazaire:
bad representation? dude, shut up, it's an amazing piece, i didn't even notice the jaw thing till i read it in your description. even though you pay to much attention to it, you do start to see it, it really isn't noticeable at face value, and doesn't really detract from the piece as a whole

--
"If I sued you for all you're worth, I could buy the universe."


-Me.

(oh, and check out my gallery plzz?)
:icontwotimehero:
Hmm. I can see how some might say the jaw looks a little big, to me it looks as it could have ended at the first curve from the jaw. I guess I just can't see the depth in the top of the snout ^^; but even with that minor flaw, its still looks great. Nobody can do everything perfect.
:iconchrisscalf:
Yeah, but watch! Someone will say something soon! Just wait! ;-) I say this in fun way. :-) Just check the youtube vid comments. Scroll back in earlier pages. ;-)

It's all fun tho! :-)

Thanks for the kind words!

--
Chris Scalf
[link]
[link]
:iconkaosune:
you said it yourself

"art's so subjective"
like it heaps, looks so subjective uoy

--
[link] go and rate plz

'Even though I knew it was bound to happen it still hurt, like a knife through my heart, stabbing and destroying.' - ~Nakamura-Chiaki
:iconkaosune:
you just said that some people like it yet you don't?

>_>

--
[link] go and rate plz

'Even though I knew it was bound to happen it still hurt, like a knife through my heart, stabbing and destroying.' - ~Nakamura-Chiaki
:icongildedlink:
This is interesting, and I'm gonna take it as a challenge to play devil's advocate and figure out what they're saying about the jaw- as a quick aside, I believe this was one of the youtube vids that led to me finding your work in the first place, so obviously I think it's damn good in any case.

The main place I could see where people get the confusion confusion is the triangular area created by the jet of flame, the dragon's upper left fang, and the bottom left jawline. Honestly either way I end up looking at the width of the nose and the angle of the jet of flame, and thus the closest thing to a solid theory I can manage is twofold:

The angle of the flame shooting out of the dragon's mouth seems to conflict with the bottom jaw and the back of the neck. It's clear where you wanted the flame to go, and that combined with the really sharp curve of the dragon's upper neck seem to create two different primary points of perspective for the whole thing. It puts you into a predicament: If the jet of flames were adjusted more horizontally, it'd hit the corner of the page, and that's obviously not something readily accepted as good design convention, so you probably automatically pushed aside when thinking of the complete image- the upside would be that it'd look more like it's coming from the dragon's gullet. But because the nose and flame lines are parallel, and the rest of it kind of depends on how sharp you make the curve in its neck, it seems to make the bottom jaw look bent when you focus on it in that context.

--
=+= gildedlink

SpinningGrinningBelievingDecievingWhirlingTwirlingConfusingAmusingDiscoveryRecoveryInherencyTransparencyFusionConclusionRealityFatality. Merry go round your head - awake, asleep, alive, or dead.
:iconrcardoso530:
i remember when i very first started looking at coloring images i came across this one on youtube and it truly amazed me on how one could put layer upon layer and come up with something just awesome!!! it will always be one of my favorites

good job chris

--
check out the rest of my gallery: ([link])
:iconke-m72:
Hey, I'm doing a presentation on you in class tomorrow, I made sure to leave this one out.

Details

June 8
527 KB
527 KB
800×571

Statistics

46
135 [who?]
2,869 (7 today)
190 (2 today)

Share

Link
Embed
Thumb

Site Map